Re-engagement email campaign for a large newsletter list
A three-email re-engagement sequence with subject lines and timing, who to include, how to send it in batches, and what to do with people who never reply.
A re-engagement campaign is three emails over about two weeks to subscribers who stopped clicking. Each one asks a single question: do you still want this? Anyone who clicks goes back on the active list. Anyone who stays silent after the third email is suppressed. On a large list, send it in batches, starting with the people who went quiet most recently, so a bad batch never hits your whole reputation at once.
Who to include
Start from a clear definition of inactive. Use clicks, not opens. Apple Mail Privacy Protection downloads remote content in the background when a message arrives (Apple’s Mail privacy settings), so many people show as openers without reading anything.
| Include | Leave out |
|---|---|
| No click in your inactivity window (90 days for a daily list, 180 for a weekly one) | People who joined within the window |
| Subscribers who still accept mail | Hard bounces and complaints (already suppressed) |
| Readers moved to a digest who still don’t click | Paying customers you reach through account email (SaaS) |
The window depends on how often you send. A daily reader who hasn’t clicked in 90 days has ignored about 90 editions. The full reasoning, with windows for each frequency, is in a sunset policy for inactive subscribers.
On EmailMarketer.io you don’t need to clean out bounces and complaints first. Hard bounces are suppressed at once, soft bounces after three, and complaints from feedback loops are unsubscribed and suppressed automatically.
Send it in batches
Inactive addresses are the riskiest part of your list. Some have been abandoned and some belong to people who will press “Report spam” when you reappear. Send to all of them at once and one bad day lands on your whole reputation.
Split the group by when each person last clicked, and start with the most recent:
Batch 1: Not clicked in the last 90 days AND clicked in the last 180 days
Batch 2: Not clicked in the last 180 days AND clicked in the last 365 days
Batch 3: Not clicked in the last 365 days
On EmailMarketer.io, each batch is a segment. Segments filter on clicked and not clicked with a time filter, and a rule group can combine both rules.
Rules for moving through the batches:
- Start batch 1 and watch bounces and complaints on the first email.
- Start the next batch only when the previous one stayed inside your limits.
- Keep each day’s total sending close to your normal volume. Google advises against sudden volume spikes, such as doubling what you usually send (Google’s sender guidelines).
- Stop if complaints rise. Google asks senders to keep the spam rate below 0.1% and never reach 0.3%.
The three emails
Keep every email short and plain. One question, one button, a way to change frequency, and a visible unsubscribe link. Do not hide the way out. A reader who can’t find it will use the spam button instead.
| When | Job | Example subject lines | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Day 0 | Ask if they still want the newsletter | “Do you still want the morning briefing?” / “Still reading? One click keeps you on the list” |
| 2 | Day 4 | Offer less email | “Want us to email you less often?” / “Switch to the weekly edition” |
| 3 | Day 10 | Say when you will stop | “We’ll stop sending on Friday” / “Last email unless you click” |
Email 1: the question
Remind them what the newsletter is and why they signed up. Show the best recent pieces as links. Each link counts as a click and tells you they are still interested.
Subject: Do you still want the morning briefing?
You signed up for the morning briefing, but you haven't clicked a link
in a while. We'd rather send it only to people who read it.
[ Keep me subscribed ]
Prefer less email? Switch to the weekly edition.
Done with us? Unsubscribe here.
Email 2: the lighter option
Many inactive readers don’t want zero email. They want less. Offer the weekly digest as the main button. Track that link, and move everyone who clicks it to the digest list instead of back to daily.
Email 3: the deadline
Give a date. Tell them that if they don’t click, they won’t get the newsletter after it. Then follow through.
What counts as a response
A click on any link except unsubscribe counts. So does a reply, if someone reads your reply inbox. Opens do not count, for the reason above.
| Response | Action |
|---|---|
| Clicked “keep me subscribed” or any article link | Back to the active segment, every edition |
| Clicked the weekly option | Move to the digest list |
| Unsubscribed | Unsubscribed. Nothing else to do |
| No click after email 3 and a 7-day wait | Suppress |
Suppress rather than delete. A suppressed address stays on record, so a later import can’t add it back by mistake. If the person signs up again through your form, they have opted in again.
Build it as a journey
A three-step sequence with waits and checks is what journeys are for. In EmailMarketer.io, a journey has triggers, wait steps, decision steps and email steps. A decision step uses the same rules as segments, so it can check whether the person clicked within the last few days.
Trigger: contact enters the journey (API call or tag added)
│
├─ Email 1: "Do you still want the morning briefing?"
├─ Wait 4 days
├─ Decision: clicked in the last 4 days?
│ yes → exit (back to active)
│ no ↓
├─ Email 2: "Want us to email you less often?"
├─ Wait 6 days
├─ Decision: clicked in the last 6 days?
│ yes → exit
│ no ↓
├─ Email 3: "We'll stop sending on Friday"
├─ Wait 7 days
└─ Decision: clicked in the last 7 days?
yes → exit
no → webhook to your system, then suppress
Journey triggers include a manual trigger through the API and a tag being added, so you can start each batch when you are ready. A webhook step can notify your own system about the people who didn’t respond. Journeys show stats per step, so you can see how many people each email brought back.
After the last batch finishes, check your main segments. The active segment should now hold only people who click.
Checklist
- Define inactive by clicks, with a window that fits your frequency.
- Leave out new subscribers and anyone your product still needs to reach.
- Split inactive subscribers into batches by last click. Most recent first.
- Write three short emails: the question, the lighter option, the deadline.
- Build the sequence as a journey with waits and click checks.
- Watch bounces and complaints after each batch before starting the next.
- Move clickers back to active or to the digest.
- Suppress everyone who stayed silent. Don’t delete them.
- Run the campaign again on a schedule, so the inactive group never grows large.
See journeys for what the builder can do. If you run a daily or weekly newsletter, the publishers page covers sending at that volume on EmailMarketer.io.